The Shackled Leviathan: Representative Sovereignty, the UN Security Council, and the Responsibility to Protect
The potential empowerment of the UN System as a result of the Responsibility to Protect doctrine requires an examination of what it could mean for both state sovereignty and the authority of the UN Security Council. I argue that the Security Council is already a sovereign body within the international system that would be greatly empowered by the implementation of the Responsibility to Protect doctrine and the veto reform efforts of the Accountability, Transparency and Coherence (ACT) Group. I rely on Carl Schmitt’s influential definition of sovereignty and his key takeaways regarding the 1919 German constitution to illustrate the existence of two distinct levels of Schmittian-like sovereigns in the international system: state sovereigns and representative sovereigns. I will then describe the authority and structure of the Security Council followed by a brief case study of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization’s (NATO) intervention in Kosovo as an example of how real-life situations challenge the Security Council’s ability to exercise its role as a representative sovereign, including a discussion about how it can either fail to act or choose not to act and the difference between them. Afterwards, I will discuss the Responsibility to Protect doctrine and how it expands the relative power of representative sovereignty at the cost of reducing the relative power of state sovereignty, culminating in a discussion of what attempts to reform the veto power on the Security Council may do to the Council’s sovereignty. Finally, I will conclude with a discussion of the key takeaways of this paper and some further considerations.
- Author (aut): Vega, Cameron Johnathan
- Thesis director: Perez, Luke
- Committee member: Levin, Irina
- Contributor (ctb): Historical, Philosophical & Religious Studies
- Contributor (ctb): Historical, Philosophical & Religious Studies
- Contributor (ctb): School of Politics and Global Studies
- Contributor (ctb): School of Civic & Economic Thought and Leadership
- Contributor (ctb): School of Politics and Global Studies
- Contributor (ctb): School of Politics and Global Studies
- Contributor (ctb): School of Politics and Global Studies
- Contributor (ctb): School of Social Transformation
- Contributor (ctb): Historical, Philosophical & Religious Studies, Sch
- Contributor (ctb): Historical, Philosophical & Religious Studies, Sch
- Contributor (ctb): Barrett, The Honors College