With the development and successful landing of the NASA Perseverance rover, there has been growing interest in identifying how evidence of ancient life may be preserved and recognized in the geologic record. Environments that enable fossilization of biological remains are termed, “taphonomic windows”, wherein signatures of past life may be detected. In this dissertation, I have sought to identify taphonomic windows in planetary-analog environments with an eye towards the exploration of Mars. In the first chapter, I describe how evidence of past microbial life may be preserved within serpentinizing systems. Owing to energetic rock-water reactions, these systems are known to host lithotrophic and organotrophic microbial communities. By investigating drill cores from the Samail Ophiolite in Oman, I report morphological and associated chemical biosignatures preserved in these systems as a result of subsurface carbonation. As serpentinites are known to occur on Mars and potentially other planetary bodies, these deposits potentially represent high-priority targets in the exploration for past microbial life. Next, I investigated samples from Atacama Desert, Chile, to understand how evidence of life may be preserved in ancient sediments formed originally in evaporative playa lakes. Here, I describe organic geochemical and morphological evidence of life preserved within sulfate-dominated evaporite rocks from the Jurassic-Cretaceous Tonel Formation and Oligocene San Pedro Formation. Because evaporative lakes are considered to have been potentially widespread on Mars, these deposits may represent additional key targets to search for evidence of past life. In the final chapter, I describe the fossilization potential of surficial carbonates by investigating Crystal Geyser, an active cold spring environment. Here, carbonate minerals precipitate rapidly in the presence of photosynthetic microbial mat communities. I describe how potential biosignatures are initially captured by mineralization, including cell-like structures and microdigitate stromatolites. However, these morphological signatures quickly degrade owing to diagenetic dissolution and recrystallization reactions, as well as textural coarsening that homogenizes the carbonate fabric. Overall, my dissertation underscores the complexity of microbial fossilization and highlights chemically-precipitating environments that may serve as high-priority targets for astrobiological exploration.