Phosphorus (P), an essential nutrient for growth of all organisms, is often in limited biological supply for herbivore consumers compared to other elements, such as carbon (C). Ecological stoichiometry studies have assessed responses of filter-feeding zooplankton from the genus Daphnia to single and multi-species food resources that are P-limited, finding decreased growth as a result to changes in metabolic processes and feeding behavior. Conversely, recent laboratory studies have shown that P-rich algal food resources also result in decreased growth rates for Daphnia, though the possible mechanisms behind this maladaptive response is understudied. Moreover, no published study tests the existence of the “stoichiometric knife edge” hypothesis for low C:P under field conditions. To address this lack of information, I measured growth rate as well as respiration and ingestion rates for D. magna, D. pulicaria, and D. pulex that were fed natural lake seston experimentally enriched with different levels of PO43-. I found heterogeneous effects of high dietary P across Daphnia species. Growth rate responses for D. magna were strong and indicated a negative effect of high-P, most likely as a result to decreased ingestion rates that were observed. The seston treatments did not elicit significant growth rate responses for D. pulex and D. pulicaria, but significant responses to respiration rates were observed for all species. Consumer body stoichiometry, differences in seston C:P for each experiment, or differential assimilation by producer types may be driving these results. My study suggests that the stoichiometric knife edge documented in laboratory studies under low C:P conditions may not operate to the same degree when natural seston is the food source; diet diversity may be driving complex nuances for consumer performance that were previously overlooked.