Competitive Adsorption of Arsenic over Phosphate on Porphyrin: a DFT study

Using DFT calculations and GAMESS computational software, porphine and its derivatives were analyzed for unique sites to accept the adsorbates As(III), As(V) and P(V) in order to compare resulting adsorption energies and determine if any of these molecules prefer arsenic oxyanions over phosphate. Pure porphine preferred As(III) over P(V) with a resulting adsorption energy of -0.7974 eV. Of the functionalized porphyrins tested, carboxyl porphyrin preferred As(V) over P(V) with a total adsorption energy of -0.7345 eV. Ethyl, methyl, chlorine and amino porphyrin all preferred As(III), with energies of -0.7934, -0.8239, -0.7602, and -0.8508 eV, respectively. Of the metalated porphyrins tested, copper and vanadium porphyrin preferred As(V) over P(V) with adsorption energies of -0.7645 and -2.0915 eV. Chromium, iron and magnesium porphyrin all preferred As(III) over P(V) with energies of -0.5993, -1.4539, and - 1.0790 eV, respectively.