Defining the Limitations of Illumina Amplicon Sequencing as it Relates to Community Diversity Analysis

The termite Coptotermes gestroi is a small subterranean termite originating from Southeast Asia. The hindgut of C. gestroi contains five distinct species of parabasalid: Pseudotrichonympha leei, two undescribed species from the genus Holomastigotoides, and two undescribed species from the genus Cononympha. This study investigates the protist symbionts in C. gestroi and the relationship between their relative abundance as inferred by Illumina sequence reads and the directly observed abundances for each protist genus. Illumina amplicon sequencing as a means of DNA analysis is a proven method for identification and diversity analysis, although the specific ratios of sequence reads to cell abundance in protists is not well known. In this study, protist communities were observed under light microscopy; cells were counted under hemocytometer and characterized at the molecular level using Illumina amplicon sequencing. When comparing sequence read abundances to cell abundances, some general trends were found in both analysis methods. Cononmypha repeatedly formed the majority of the community, while Holomastigotoides and Pseudotrichonympha were responsible for a smaller yet similar portion of the population. Cell counts and sequence reads were also compared using an assumed linear model, with R2 values generated to quantify the relationship between both. The results suggest that Illumina sequencing can be used to obtain rough estimates of community diversity, but the high variability within the data suggest that the read abundances should be treated with caution.